• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Reviews
    • Our Team
      • Brandon Osterbind
      • Kelly Osterbind
      • Hannah Bowie
      • Cameron Andrews
      • Robert Vogel, MD, JD
      • Julia Hinckle
      • Karen Bowen
      • Brittany Hertzberg
      • Leah Gale
      • Isabelle Carter
    • Firm Overview
    • Lawyer Referrals
    • General Referrals
    • Podcast
    • Newsletters
    • Careers
    • Communication Policy
    • Website Disclaimer
  • Personal Injury Cases
    • Car Accidents
    • Tractor Trailer Accidents
    • Drunk Driving Car Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Faulty Products Causing Injury
    • Dog Bite Injuries
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Slip and Fall Injuries
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Wrongful Death
  • Disability Denials
    • Aetna Disability Denials
    • Cigna Disability Denials
    • The Hartford Disability Denials
    • Liberty Mutual Disability Denials
    • Lincoln Financial Group Disability Denials
    • Met Life Disability Denials
    • Mutual of Omaha Disability Denials
    • Principal Financial Disability Denials
    • Prudential Disability Denials
    • Reliance Standard Disability Denials
    • Standard Insurance Disability Denials
  • Results
  • Free Info
    • Blog
      • Personal Injury
      • ERISA Disability
      • Workers’ Compensation
      • Medical Malpractice
      • Wrongful Death
    • Free Injury and Disability Books
    • Personal Injury Settlement Calculator
    • Personal Injury FAQ Videos
    • ERISA Long-Term Disability FAQ Videos
    • Client Portal
  • Contact
    • Book Now!

Lynchburg VA Personal Injury Lawyers

Trial Lawyers.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
CALL TODAY : (434) 515-2807
Free Strategy Session
Call
Contact
Blog
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Reviews
    • Our Team
      • Brandon Osterbind
      • Kelly Osterbind
      • Hannah Bowie
      • Cameron Andrews
      • Robert Vogel, MD, JD
      • Julia Hinckle
      • Karen Bowen
      • Brittany Hertzberg
      • Leah Gale
      • Isabelle Carter
    • Firm Overview
    • Lawyer Referrals
    • General Referrals
    • Podcast
    • Newsletters
    • Careers
    • Communication Policy
    • Website Disclaimer
  • Personal Injury Cases
    • Car Accidents
    • Tractor Trailer Accidents
    • Drunk Driving Car Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Faulty Products Causing Injury
    • Dog Bite Injuries
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Slip and Fall Injuries
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Wrongful Death
  • Disability Denials
    • Aetna Disability Denials
    • Cigna Disability Denials
    • The Hartford Disability Denials
    • Liberty Mutual Disability Denials
    • Lincoln Financial Group Disability Denials
    • Met Life Disability Denials
    • Mutual of Omaha Disability Denials
    • Principal Financial Disability Denials
    • Prudential Disability Denials
    • Reliance Standard Disability Denials
    • Standard Insurance Disability Denials
  • Results
  • Free Info
    • Blog
      • Personal Injury
      • ERISA Disability
      • Workers’ Compensation
      • Medical Malpractice
      • Wrongful Death
    • Free Injury and Disability Books
    • Personal Injury Settlement Calculator
    • Personal Injury FAQ Videos
    • ERISA Long-Term Disability FAQ Videos
    • Client Portal
  • Contact
    • Book Now!

$260,000 Pedestrian Accident Verdict in Farmville, Virginia

22 Jun 2023

Pedestrian accidents are always difficult for a number of reasons. First, they involve significant injuries and a lot of medical treatment. Second, the driver of the car almost always blames the pedestrian. It is notable when a jury awards a significant verdict to a pedestrian. That is exactly what happened in this case.

Farmville Pedestrian Accident

Our client was a pedestrian walking across Main Street in Farmville, Virginia. The Defendant failed to yield to her in the crosswalk.

The injured pedestrian was a freshman at Longwood at the time. The Defendant quite literally drove through her.

Our Client’s Injuries

Our client was lucky that she only suffered an ACL and MCL tear. Even though she had an extensive surgery, her medical expenses were only $47,000.00. This is fairly low for pedestrian accidents. She only had 7 months of treatment which included the surgery and physical therapy. Her physical therapy was spotty. Four months after she was hit and two months after surgery, she started telling her doctor and physical therapist that she had 0 out of 10 pain.

The Lawsuit

We attempted a global settlement after identifying a liability insurance policy for $100,000 and two UIM policies adding up to $200,000. The UIM policies receive an offset for the liability policy. That means there was $100,000 available from the liability policy and $100,000 available from the UIM policy.

We settled with the liability carrier (Progressive) early on for policy limits of 100,000. The UIM carrier (State Farm) offered $25,000 of the $100,000 coverage available early on. We filed suit in the Circuit Court for Prince Edward County. The judge required a judicial settlement conference. State Farm came to the mediation and all they had to offer was the same $25,000 that was previously offered. It was a short mediation. And, they never made another offer.

The Trial

About a month prior to trial, opposing counsel admitted liability for the pedestrian accident. He presented no evidence at trial. We had six witnesses including our expert. Osterbind Law attorney Hannah Bowie also called the defendant as an adverse witness. Opposing counsel asked less than 10 questions on cross-examination over the course of the trial.

As with all trials, jury selection was critical. We were not excited about the jury pool from the get-go, but we were proven wrong. It’s important that we do our homework on people, but we learned that we need to release our judgments when jurors say things that may be contrary to what we originally thought about them. The jury we picked included a man that was old friends with two of the defendant’s family members, a man that had been a defendant in a personal injury case and who said he had a difficult time quantifying pain and suffering, and a bank manager. Hannah was able to get the jury pool talking. At one point, they were responding to what each other were saying.

Our witnesses were excellent. Each brought a different dynamic and different perspective to issue of damages. Our client was stoic. She did the best she could, but talking about her injuries and life after was hard for her.

In closing, opposing counsel objected to Hannah saying the defendant had not taken responsibility for the incident even though liability had been admitted. The judge wrongfully shut her down pretty quick. From our perspective, the defendant accepts responsibility when he or she makes the plaintiff whole.

Opposing counsel hammered that the jury needed to be fair to the defendant. In rebuttal, Hannah asked them to read the instructions carefully because they won’t find an instruction that says to be fair to the defendant. After the trial, Hannah spoke with a juror who said this clarification greatly impacted the damages discussion. Hannah asked the jury for a damages award of a little over $372,000.00.

The Result

After an hour of deliberations, the jury came back with an award of $260,000.00 with interest from the date of pedestrian accident.

Hannah said, “Overall this was a fun trial. It was a team effort for sure.”

The Disclaimer

The Virginia State Bar requires that we give a disclaimer whenever we talk about case results. As we are sure you already know, the case result described above must be read in context with the unique facts of this particular case. Each case result depends upon a variety of factors unique to each case, which is why we describe those facts in detail. To be clear, this case result does not guarantee or predict a similar result in any future case undertaken by the lawyers at Osterbind Law, PLLC.

Primary Sidebar

Download Our Free Books!

Can We Help?

Reviews

Related Blogs

  • $850,000 Traumatic Brain Injury Settlement

    25 Mar 2025

    At Read More

  • Spinal Injury Victim Wins $890,000 Settlement

    25 Oct 2024

    At Read More

  • $260,000 Pedestrian Accident Verdict in Farmville, Virginia

    22 Jun 2023

    Pedestrian Read More

Case Results

$940,000 in Settlements For Broken Clavicle and Torn Rotator Cuff

Personal Injury | Workers’ Compensation

View Project
Traumatic Brain injury Results In $395,000 in settlement

Personal Injury | Workers’ Compensation

View Project
$280,000 Settlement for Labral Tear after Rear-End Collision

Personal Injury

View Project
  • Disability Insurance
  • Personal Injury
  • Workers Comp
  • Medical Malpractice

Footer

Free Strategy Session

Legal Awards

Client Reviews


Brandon and his team at Osterbind Law are truly peerless. This is exactly how a modern personal injury firm should operate. The firm is holistic in its approach and thoughtful. It's no wonder why they get such great results for their clients. And no surprise, their clients love them. I've had the pleasure of working with Brandon on a professional level and he levels up, big time. Kudos.
Nathaniel Amendola
3 months ago

Very compassionate and knowledgeable people who helped us with our situation. They worked quickly and I can’t tell you how grateful I’m they were so caring. I would recommend this firm to anyone that anyone
Lori Rudder
a year ago

The entire team at Osterbind Law are incredible. They communicated with us with every step and process that was happening . They provided the knowledge, support, and empathy to us on the case. And when the curve ball was thrown, they dug in deeper. I have nothing but the highest respect for Brandon and Hannah and the entire team. They made us feel more like a family, than a client.
Wendy Shull
a year ago

The staff is caring and very knowledgeable. They help you as quickly as possible, and worked very hard for us. I'm so pleased with the way they assisted us.
Meghan Rudder
a year ago

Brandon and his team did a great job helping me through my case. I'm so glad I chose him and stuck with him through the transition to his own firm. The staff is very knowledgeable and friendly. They feel like family after all this! Thank you for everything!!Amber J
Amber Higby
2 year ago
Read More ReviewsWrite a Review
  • 1216 Greenview Drive, Suite A
    Lynchburg, VA 24502
  • Email Us    Privacy Policy
  • Call Us
    (434) 515-2807

© 2025 Virginia Personal Injury and Disability Lawyers. All rights reserved.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Quick Help