At Osterbind Law, PLLC, we recently secured a $123,000 settlement for a client injured in a commercial vehicle crash in downtown Lynchburg, Virginia. After years of litigation, and an insurance company that played games from the start, our team—led by Brandon Osterbind—pushed the case forward until justice was done.
If you’re looking for a Lynchburg personal injury lawyer for shoulder injury, this case shows how persistence and teamwork can overcome insurance resistance and lead to real results.
The Crash: Tractor Trailer Runs Red Light in Downtown Lynchburg
Our client was driving through an intersection in downtown Lynchburg when a tractor trailer ran a red light, crashing into his vehicle. The commercial driver insisted he had a green light, but multiple eyewitnesses were ready to testify that the truck driver was at fault.
Our client was transported to the hospital with complaints of neck, back, and shoulder pain. While the back and neck pain resolved with physical therapy at Rehab Associates of Central Virginia, the shoulder pain persisted.
The Injury: Torn Rotator Cuff Requires Surgery
As the pain continued, our client returned to OrthoVirginia, where an MRI confirmed a rotator cuff tear. His orthopedic surgeon linked the injury directly to the crash, noting that the shoulder pain began at the time of the accident and had been consistent ever since.
Surgery was performed to repair the tear, followed by several months of rehabilitation. The result was largely successful—our client regained the use of his shoulder, which was crucial given his physically demanding job. Still, he’s occasionally reminded that it’s not quite what it used to be.
The Lawsuit: Insurance Games and Strategic Litigation
As the statute of limitations approached, we filed suit while our client was still treating. Initially, we withheld service to give the client time to finish medical treatment and to attempt a resolution. After submitting a settlement demand, the insurance company responded with a lowball offer of $37,000—barely covering medical expenses.
Eventually, they increased the offer to $50,000 but claimed they weren’t even factoring in the shoulder surgery—despite every doctor connecting the injury to the crash and no evidence of a pre-existing condition.
We knew they weren’t being honest. The non-shoulder medical bills totaled only around $7,000. No insurer would offer $50,000 for minor soft tissue injuries alone. It was clear: the insurance company was trying to lowball and bluff its way through the negotiation.
The Resolution: Pressure, Persistence, and a Strong Team
Brandon Osterbind led the charge on litigation and discovery, while David Abraham stayed in close communication with the insurance adjuster. Together, they applied steady pressure—demanding records, pushing deadlines, and preparing for trial.
The strategy worked. As the defense realized we were fully prepared to try the case and their position was untenable, they incrementally increased their offers—ultimately agreeing to a $123,000 settlement.
Why You Need a Lynchburg Personal Injury Lawyer for Shoulder Injuries
Shoulder injuries—especially rotator cuff tears that require surgery—are often underestimated by insurance companies. But for people with physically active jobs, full recovery isn’t just about comfort—it’s about livelihood.
If you’ve suffered a shoulder injury after a car accident, don’t trust the insurance company to do the right thing. You need a lawyer who understands the medicine, the strategy, and the pressure points.
Talk to a Lynchburg Personal Injury Lawyer Today
Osterbind Law helps people throughout Central Virginia recover after life-changing injuries. We offer free consultations and don’t get paid unless we recover money for you.
📞 Call (434) 515-2807
🌐 www.osterbindlaw.com
Disclaimer: Every case is unique. The outcome described here is based on the specific facts, treatment, and litigation strategy involved. This result does not guarantee or predict similar outcomes in future cases.
