• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Firm Overview
    • Lawyer Referrals
    • General Referrals
    • Podcast
    • Newsletters
    • Careers
    • Communication Policy
  • Personal Injury Cases
    • Car Accidents
    • Tractor Trailer Accidents
    • Drunk Driving Car Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Faulty Products Causing Injury
    • Dog Bite Injuries
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Slip and Fall Injuries
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Wrongful Death
  • Disability Insurance Denials
  • Results
  • Reviews
  • Blog
    • Personal Injury
    • ERISA Disability
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Wrongful Death
  • Free Info
    • Free Injury and Disability Books
    • Personal Injury Settlement Calculator
    • Win Your Own Personal Injury Case
    • Personal Injury FAQ Videos
    • ERISA Long-Term Disability FAQ Videos
    • Client Portal
  • Contact
    • Book Now!

Virginia Personal Injury and Disability Lawyers

Trial Lawyers.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
CALL TODAY : (434) 515-2807
Free Strategy Session
Call
Contact
Blog
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Firm Overview
    • Lawyer Referrals
    • General Referrals
    • Podcast
    • Newsletters
    • Careers
    • Communication Policy
  • Personal Injury Cases
    • Car Accidents
    • Tractor Trailer Accidents
    • Drunk Driving Car Accidents
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Faulty Products Causing Injury
    • Dog Bite Injuries
    • Pedestrian Accidents
    • Slip and Fall Injuries
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Wrongful Death
  • Disability Insurance Denials
  • Results
  • Reviews
  • Blog
    • Personal Injury
    • ERISA Disability
    • Workers’ Compensation
    • Medical Malpractice
    • Wrongful Death
  • Free Info
    • Free Injury and Disability Books
    • Personal Injury Settlement Calculator
    • Win Your Own Personal Injury Case
    • Personal Injury FAQ Videos
    • ERISA Long-Term Disability FAQ Videos
    • Client Portal
  • Contact
    • Book Now!

It has been a year since I tried my consumer protection act case

7 Mar 2015

It has been a year since I tried what I affectionately refer to as my leaky basement case to a jury. On behalf of my client, I sued a home seller for common law fraud and two violations of the Virginia Consumer Protection Act (the “VCPA”). The case was tried by a jury, which is the most important civil right in both the Virginia and United States Constitutions.

Despite some overlap, these causes of action are very different in that one is a common law cause of action and another is a statutory cause of action. At trial, I argued that the burden of proof for common law fraud is—without question—clear and convincing evidence, but the burden of proof for a violation of the VCPA is a preponderance of the evidence. The difference between these two burdens is great and heavily influences a jury’s decision on a case.

I liken these burdens to a game of football where a preponderance gets the football into your opponent’s territory by one yard and clear and convincing gets you into field goal range. Both are less than beyond a reasonable doubt in criminal cases which is like the football slightly crossing the plane of the goal line for a touchdown.

The trial judge ruled that the burden of proof for both was clear and convincing evidence. After the jury returned a verdict for the defense, my client filed her notice of appeal in the trial court and, then, her petition for appeal in the Supreme Court of Virginia. The Defendant replied to the petition for appeal and I argued for a writ back in December 2014. The Supreme Court decided that the issue is one that needs to be decided in Virginia and took the case.

Then, I filed an opening brief providing legal support for my position and to my surprise, several other state and national organizations joined in on an amicus brief in support of my client’s position. Even the Attorney General of Virginia filed an amicus brief in my client’s favor. The Appellee filed its brief and now it is my turn to file a Reply Brief, which is due on Monday.

It has been one year after the jury trial on this case and we still do not have any resolution to the issue at hand. The Supreme Court will likely hear oral arguments on this case in April and if we win, the case will be remanded for retrial on the Consumer Protection Act claims.

I can honestly say that I have never known more about the VCPA than I do right now. I’ve always said that law school doesn’t teach you every sophisticated nuance about the law but it teaches you how to think like a lawyer and how to become an expert in the case at hand. I feel that is certainly true in this case. My hope is that it pays off for my client.

Primary Sidebar

Download Our Free Books!

Related Blogs

  • How to stop phone calls from frustrating telemarketers

    19 Jul 2017

    You’re Read More

  • My First Trip To The Supreme Court Of Virginia

    22 Jul 2015

    It Read More

  • It has been a year since I tried my consumer protection act case

    7 Mar 2015

    It Read More

Case Results

$940,000 in Settlements For Broken Clavicle and Torn Rotator Cuff

Personal Injury | Workers’ Compensation

View Project
Traumatic Brain injury Results In $395,000 in settlement

Personal Injury | Workers’ Compensation

View Project
$280,000 Settlement for Labral Tear after Rear-End Collision

Personal Injury

View Project

Reviews

Free Strategy Session

Footer

Free Strategy Session

Legal Awards

Client Reviews


Brandon and his team at Osterbind Law are truly peerless. This is exactly how a modern personal injury firm should operate. The firm is holistic in its approach and thoughtful. It's no wonder why they get such great results for their clients. And no surprise, their clients love them. I've had the pleasure of working with Brandon on a professional level and he levels up, big time. Kudos.
Nathaniel Amendola
3 months ago

Very compassionate and knowledgeable people who helped us with our situation. They worked quickly and I can’t tell you how grateful I’m they were so caring. I would recommend this firm to anyone that anyone
Lori Rudder
a year ago

The entire team at Osterbind Law are incredible. They communicated with us with every step and process that was happening . They provided the knowledge, support, and empathy to us on the case. And when the curve ball was thrown, they dug in deeper. I have nothing but the highest respect for Brandon and Hannah and the entire team. They made us feel more like a family, than a client.
Wendy Shull
a year ago

The staff is caring and very knowledgeable. They help you as quickly as possible, and worked very hard for us. I'm so pleased with the way they assisted us.
Meghan Rudder
a year ago

Brandon and his team did a great job helping me through my case. I'm so glad I chose him and stuck with him through the transition to his own firm. The staff is very knowledgeable and friendly. They feel like family after all this! Thank you for everything!!Amber J
Amber Higby
2 year ago
Read More ReviewsWrite a Review
  • 1216 Greenview Drive, Suite A
    Lynchburg, VA 24502
  • Email Us
  • Call Us
    (434) 515-2807

© 2023 Virginia Personal Injury and Disability Lawyers. All rights reserved.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Quick Help